A cappuccino and croissant on a pale stone café table beside a sunlit village window, with bare November branches and clapboard buildings outside.

Coffee Returns to the Golden Pear's Old Bridgehampton Space This Thanksgiving

The storefront at 2426 Montauk Highway in Bridgehampton has been closed since late October 2025. When it reopens, it will be a café again. Tutto Caffè, the second café from the family behind Tutto il Giorno, is scheduled to open there Thanksgiving weekend, November 27 to 29, in the former Golden Pear space. The Golden Pear had been on Main Street since 1996. The Golden Pear served Bridgehampton for nearly three decades. A café coming back after about thirteen months empty means this stretch of Montauk Highway again has a coffee counter in the same building it had for most of the past thirty years. The space reopens just as the hamlet settles into its winter hours.

Twenty-Nine Years at 2426 Montauk Highway

The Golden Pear began in Southampton Village, at the corner of Main and Nugent streets, in 1987. It added a café on Newtown Lane in East Hampton in 1991 and the Bridgehampton café in 1996. For more than a decade it also ran a café on Main Street in Sag Harbor. The Southampton Press reported that owner Keith Davis could not negotiate a new lease for the Bridgehampton space, and that the café would close at the end of October 2025.

Davis gave the paper a figure for the run: "We operated for more than 10,890 consecutive days with excellence and pride." He also left a note for the hamlet: "To our cherished Bridgehampton customers: Thank you!" In the same Southampton Press story, he said he would look for another Bridgehampton location, though he noted that few restaurant spaces of about 1,800 square feet come available here. He would not say what business was taking his place. Southforker covered the closing the week it happened.

The Golden Pear still runs two cafés nearby. The Southampton café at 99 Main Street opens at 6 a.m. every day, and the East Hampton café at 34 Newtown Lane opens at 6:30 a.m.

The New Tenant Is a Coffee Bar With a Wine List

This November, Spark Hamptons reported that the team behind Tutto il Giorno and East Hampton's Tutto Caffè is opening a second café in the former Golden Pear space. Gabby Karan de Felice designed the room, and the menu will have specialty coffee, Italian pastries, panini and light fare.

The East Hampton original gives a good idea of the format. Tutto Caffè opened at 55 Main Street in East Hampton at the end of 2022 and is open daily from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. Gianpaolo de Felice and David Mayer created it as a modern Italian-style café and bar, and Gally Mayer runs the coffee program. The café pairs coffee made from regeneratively grown beans with wine, cocktails, Italian pastries and panini. The company's own listing calls the Bridgehampton location Tutto Caffè Bridge.

The Golden Pear was a full café serving breakfast and lunch. Tutto's East Hampton model is an Italian café and bar. Both put a counter, a cup of coffee and something baked in this storefront, which is the use the space had for twenty-nine years.

Bridgehampton's Winter Morning, by Street Number

The new café opens onto a stretch of Montauk Highway where the other morning counters sit within a few hundred street numbers of it, and one of them opened seventy-one years before the Golden Pear arrived.

The Bridgehampton Candy Kitchen at 2391 Montauk Highway posts daily hours of 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. The East Hampton Star reported that it opened May 2, 1925, so this is its 102nd winter. Gus Laggis has owned it since 1981, and his daughters Jamie Laggis and Maria Laggis Lima run it day to day with his son-in-law, Mauricio Lima.

West of the Candy Kitchen, the Bridgehampton Inn Restaurant at 2266 Montauk Highway has added a newer kind of morning. The Loaves & Fishes family runs it, lists it as open year-round, and serves breakfast every day from 8 to 10:30 a.m.

On weekends, a third breakfast opens a few steps up the Turnpike. Jean-Georges at Topping Rose House, at One Bridgehampton–Sag Harbor Turnpike, serves a full hot breakfast Saturday and Sunday from 8 to 10:30 a.m. and weekend brunch from 11:30 a.m. to 3 p.m. Its weekday continental breakfast is for hotel guests only.

The posted opening times along this corridor on a winter weekday run in this order:

  1. 7 a.m.: the Candy Kitchen opens at 2391 Montauk Highway.
  2. 8 a.m.: breakfast starts at the Bridgehampton Inn at 2266 Montauk Highway and ends at 10:30.
  3. 11 a.m.: Pierre's at 2468 Main Street opens for lunch every day except Wednesday.
  4. Noon: Bobby Van's at 2393 Montauk Highway begins lunch service, which runs until 3 p.m.

The new café at 2426 sits between the Candy Kitchen and Pierre's. On Saturdays and Sundays, Topping Rose's breakfast and brunch add to the morning.

Where the Day Ends Through the Winter

Breakfast settles into a pattern quickly in winter. Dinner takes more planning, since each dining room keeps its own schedule.

Pierre's posts weekday hours of 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. and 5 to 9 p.m., is closed Wednesdays, and serves straight through from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. on Saturday and Sunday. Bobby Van's, two doors from the Candy Kitchen, serves dinner from 5 to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and until 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday. Its bar is open daily from noon to 11 p.m. At Topping Rose House, lunch is off for the season and dinner runs nightly.

Elaia Estiatorio at 95 School Street serves dinner from 5 to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and until 9:30 p.m. on Friday and Saturday. Its Opa happy hour runs every day from 5 to 6:30 p.m., and the restaurant offers indoor dining and pickup this winter.

The Bridgehampton Inn moves from breakfast to dinner Wednesday through Sunday, starting at 5:30 p.m. On September 16, 2026, the restaurant announced a new prix fixe menu served Wednesdays, Thursdays and Sundays.

Almond, at 1 Ocean Road, has the most detailed weekly calendar in the hamlet this season. The Southampton Press described a fall schedule built around a $39 two-course prix fixe served all night Monday through Thursday. Each weeknight also has its own special: a plant-focused $39 prix fixe on Meatless Mondays, a $25 burger and beer on Tuesdays, $25 bottomless mussels and fries on Wednesdays, and $10 margaritas and martinis on Thursdays. Karaoke with DJ Lama starts at 9:30 p.m. on Saturdays. The bistro is open Monday through Saturday and closed Sundays, and its 25th anniversary celebration continues this season. Executive Chef Jason Weiner is relaunching the monthly Almond Dinner & Provisions Club, which pairs an Almond meal with L&W Market sauces, pickles and spreads.

One Turnpike address is closed until spring. Nourish by The Roundtree, at 203 Bridgehampton-Sag Harbor Turnpike, has closed for the season and reopens in May.

Winter schedules on the South Fork can change on short notice, and the hours above are the ones each restaurant posts for the season, so it is worth calling before a weeknight dinner. For more on the hamlet through the year, the Bridgehampton neighborhood guide and our notes on November in the Hamptons pick up where this one ends.

For some buyers, the best address in Bridgehampton is one where the Candy Kitchen, the Inn's breakfast room and the new café at 2426 Montauk Highway are all within reach on a winter morning. The Jennifer Wilson Team can send you homes near the hamlet center, along this stretch of Montauk Highway. Get Property Listings Delivered.

Work With Jennifer

With 20 years of luxury real estate experience in the Hampton's, Jennifer Wilson offers a unique and unparalleled approach to the purchasing and marketing of luxury properties in the Hamptons. Backed by the Saunders design team, Jennifer offers her clients a comprehensive and state of the art approach to marketing that promotes her luxury listings locally and globally. In addition, her strategic partnerships with NY Title Abstract Service, award winning design and staging companies, mortgage brokers, and top local attorneys makes the buying or selling process competitive and seamless.

Follow Me on Instagram