"Some of the best holiday traditions do spring from letters written to newspapers," The East Hampton Star wrote in December 2024. The editors were looking back at a letter James R. Weldon sent them that January, which suggested that a contest might help bring back "the village's former winter warmth." The Star's own decorating contest grew out of that letter. That same December, Ralph Lauren sponsored a second contest during SantaFest.
Two years later, the storefront contest is built into the village's holiday calendar. This year the East Hampton Village Foundation's Deck the Windows contest opens on Black Friday, November 27, and runs through Saturday, December 5. Every part of SantaFest happens on or close to the blocks being judged, and the day ends with the winners announced at the tree lighting.
Every Storefront on Three Streets Is Already Entered
Shops don't sign up for this contest. The Foundation's SantaFest page says every business on Main Street, Newtown Lane and Park Place is entered automatically. The rules fit in a few lines:
- Dates: Friday, November 27 through Saturday, December 5, 2026.
- Who is eligible: Shops on Main Street, Newtown Lane and Park Place.
- Public vote: Scan the QR code posted at a participating storefront to vote for the People's Choice Award.
- Judged award: All seven members of the East Hampton Village Design Review Board serve as official judges.
- Announcement: Mayor Jerry Larsen and a special guest name the winners at the 5 p.m. tree and menorah lighting in Herrick Park on December 5.
That gives each window two separate audiences. Seven board members choose the judged winners. The People's Choice Award is decided entirely by votes from people walking past.
The 2024 Contest Raised the Question Two Juries Answer
When the Star judged its first contest in 2024, its panel hit a problem that the two-jury format answers directly. The paper called the Ralph Lauren stores "the standalone superstars of holiday window décor," and said there had been "much debate" over whether they or the Monogram Shop on Newtown Lane should win. The judges chose the Monogram Shop and said they would revise the rules for the next year.
The Star described the Monogram Shop as "a stalwart small business known for maintaining windows of much interest year round, and especially during elections." It also singled out London Jewelers' "landmark garland-wrapped columns," Obligato's "Barbie-pink tree," Dayton Ritz & Osborne's "classic Father Christmas and icicles," and the candy-striped columns at Corcoran. In 2024 those windows were judged under the Star's contest, which ran with the Anchor Society and the Greater East Hampton Chamber of Commerce. The Foundation's contest is a separate competition. Because every shop on the three streets is entered, a big flagship window and a small family-run storefront compete side by side. The design board judges one award and passersby decide the other, so one season can produce two different winners.
By December 2025, the voting was already part of the walk through town. The Star's SantaFest preview that year described QR codes on shop doors for a People's Choice Award for "best window dressing," and an Elf on the Shelf that turned up in a different business's window each day.
Saturday Morning Runs Down Main Street and Newtown Lane
On December 5, SantaFest's morning moves along two of the three contest streets. The morning schedule on the Foundation's page:
- 9 a.m. to 3 p.m.: Holiday Market at Village Hall, 86 Main Street. Local vendors, free gift wrapping by the Ladies Village Improvement Society, a gingerbread house competition, and hot cider.
- 11 a.m.: Santa lands by helicopter at Herrick Park, 67 Newtown Lane. The arrival is free. The Star noted in 2025 that the landing depends on the weather.
- Noon: The parade on Main Street and Newtown Lane. The East Hampton Village Police Department leads, floats follow, and Santa rides at the back.
The parade route on Main Street and Newtown Lane runs along storefronts that have been open to voting since Black Friday. The Foundation's application invites local businesses, nonprofits, clubs and families to march, and says "no elaborate float required." Last year, according to the Star, village historian Hugh King announced the floats as they reached the corner of Newtown Lane and Hugh King Alley.
The Afternoon Spreads Across Six Addresses
After the parade, the day splits up. Most of the afternoon programs run at the same time, all within the village center:
| Time | Program | Address |
|---|---|---|
| Noon to 5 p.m. | North Pole Ice Bar by Smokey Buns and Long Island Ice & Fuel | Alleyway beside Smokey Buns, between BookHampton and Starbucks |
| 1 to 4 p.m. | Santa's Workshop and free photos with Santa | Millstone Park, 61 Main Street |
| 1 to 4 p.m. | Candyland, from Sam's and BonBon Candy | Sam's, 36 Newtown Lane |
| 1 to 4 p.m. | Mrs. Claus at the LVIS Holiday Open House | 95 Main Street |
| 1 to 4 p.m. | Holiday cookie decorating with Citarella | Guild Hall's Boots Lamb Education Center, 158 Main Street |
| 2 p.m. | Free screening of The Polar Express | East Hampton Middle School, 76 Newtown Lane |
The posted schedule includes a few practical details. At Millstone Park, the Foundation says the line for Santa starts forming at noon, so families who head over straight from the parade will be early. East 27 Creative Photography is sponsoring the photos. The middle school screening needs no tickets, seating is first come, first served, and there is popcorn. The ice bar serves holiday cocktails to guests 21 and over, and BookHampton plans a selection of holiday books next door.
Two of these programs are also listed on the hosts' own calendars. Guild Hall lists the Citarella cookie decorating for Saturday, December 5, from 1 to 4 p.m., free and "in conjunction with SantaFest," and recommends registering in advance, though it's not required. The LVIS lists its Holiday Open House at 95 Main Street for the same afternoon, where children can visit Mrs. Claus.
Some of the program is new. Last December's screening at the middle school was Elf, according to Dan's Papers, and this year it's The Polar Express.
The Winners Are Announced Under the Tree
The day ends back at Herrick Park. Starting at 4 p.m., local school students, community music groups and carolers perform, the audience is invited to sing along, and the Foundation announces SantaFest raffle winners throughout the hour. The Village Christmas Tree and Menorah are lit at 5 p.m. The window contest winners, including the People's Choice Award, are named during that 5 p.m. ceremony.
Herrick Park draws a large crowd for this. News 12 reported that Bradford Billet, the Foundation's chairman, estimated about 4,000 people at the 2024 celebration, where every activity was free. Before the 2025 event, co-founder Mary Waserstein told the Star, "We felt like we have 2,000 people coming to Herrick Park to see Santa arrive."
The Foundation says SantaFest grew out of Mayor Larsen's goal of creating community traditions. Billet, Village Administrator Marcos Baladron and Waserstein, the Greater East Hampton Chamber of Commerce's former executive director, are credited as co-founders, and the Village and the Foundation now plan the day year-round. The 2025 edition was the fourth, according to the Star, which also wrote that because so much of the day is free, it removes "the village's omnipresent financial barrier."
The Week Before the Fifth
The contest's opening weekend falls between Thanksgiving and SantaFest, and one more village event is already on the calendar that week. On Tuesday, December 1, the East Hampton Historical Society presents "Home for the Holidays," a free holiday cabaret at the East Hampton Library, held with the library.
Last year the village also held an evening kickoff the night before SantaFest. The Star reported a Sip and Shop on Friday from 4 to 7 p.m., with stores offering drinks and carolers in Dickens-era costumes on the streets. Nonprofits also had a bigger role in 2025: the East Hampton and Springs food pantries collected food and monetary donations, and groups including Hamptons Community Outreach, Fighting Chance, Guild Hall and Project Most set up at Herrick Park for the helicopter landing.
Shops can still join the larger event. The Foundation is accepting applications for Holiday Market vendors and parade entries, and is recruiting volunteers for December 5.
Storefronts are part of how a village presents itself, and that shapes how we approach every listing we prepare for market. If you would like our weekly read on East Hampton Village, along with new properties as they come to market, Jennifer Wilson will send both to you. Get Property Listings Delivered.